Content deleted Content added
MediationBot1 (talk | contribs) A request for mediation which you are a party to has been rejected |
#REDIRECT User:Inclusionist |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
#REDIRECT [[User:Inclusionist]] |
|||
==Business Plot== |
|||
If you are not prepared to discuss the issues set out in [[Talk:Business Plot]] I will be forced to assume you don't have any meaningful input anymore. I do not think that would be a good thing, at all, for this page. -[[User:Rushyo|Rushyo]] ([[User talk:Rushyo|talk]]) 11:00, 23 June 2008 (UTC) |
|||
Falsely accusing [[User:Lao Wai|Lao Wai]] of [[WP:VAND#NOT|vandalism]] and making borderline [[WP:PA|personal attacks]] against him are completely unacceptable. He has tried to bring about a discussion to reach a consensus and you have ignored him, instead accusing him of vandalism for a perfectly reasonable, if bold, edit. Your behaviour appears to be trying to make a [[WP:POINT|point]]. This doesn't help anyone, least of all the page. If you continue, you are simply invalidating your own arguments through hypocrisy! -[[User:Rushyo|Rushyo]] ([[User talk:Rushyo|talk]]) 22:09, 25 June 2008 (UTC) |
|||
The fact is when I joined the discussion you did not hold the moral high ground however per my remit under [[WP:Third opinion]] I was not going to say anything. Then Lao Wai showed a faithful respect to others and you demonstrated a complete lack of it. Frankly, I am somewhat saddened that you were prepared to use [[WP:Third opinion]] purely as a vehicle for achieving your own ends, rather than in the spirit it is intended to be used. Hence now I'm acting beyond that remit under my capacity as a peer, whether you feel me a 'inferior' peer or otherwise. |
|||
You may have been a Wikipedia editor for three years, but that doesn't grant you an immutable grasp on maturity, logic, respect and debate... and as stated yourself you "[...] learned some new acroynms and new rules." Rules which I can only presume I grasped faster than you simply by having dedicated lots of my free time to researching the policies underlying this incident. |
|||
The ability to change one's mind with respect to new information is essential to achieving a consensus, whether on Wikipedia or anything else. I am not bitter about Wikipedia, but it appears you are. I respect Wikipedia's amazing ability to bring about swift consensus on amazingly contentious issues through an unwieldy bureaucratic vehicle. In hindsight of course it is 'predictable' I behaved the way I did. It was, at the risk of foregoing modesty, the reasonable thing to do given the circumstances. |
|||
Also, might I suggest you learn the definition of bitter. Ironically it describes your emotional response to this perfectly, whereas I really don't have anything to be resentful about. I'm here to learn and to educate others where I can. I have learnt a lot from this experience and feel I've helped Lao Wai become more familiar with protocol. Hence, I have no reason to feel resentful or anguished by this. I'm just disappointed I couldn't fix things to everyone's satisfaction but you can't win them all and looking back I stand by my actions given the information available to me. |
|||
There's still plenty of opportunity to discuss this with Lao Wai... and it somewhat perplexes me why you choose to ignore that opportunity. -[[User:Rushyo|Rushyo]] ([[User talk:Rushyo|talk]]) 11:26, 27 June 2008 (UTC) |
|||
:your response puzzles me, you must have taken my brief thank you comments on your user page differently than I ever intended them. My thank you on your user page was intended only as a "thank you" and nothing more. [[User:RWV|RWV]] ([[User talk:RWV#top|talk]]) 18:08, 27 June 2008 (UTC) |
|||
==Request for mediation not accepted== |
|||
{| class="messagebox" style="width:90%" |
|||
|- |
|||
|[[Image:Exquisite-folder4.png|75px]] |
|||
|A [[Wikipedia:Requests for mediation|Request for Mediation]] to which you were are a party was [[Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Common reasons for rejection|not accepted]] and has been delisted.<br>You can find more information on the case subpage, [[Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Business Plot]].</center><br> |
|||
::''For the Mediation Committee,'' <font face="Verdana">[[User:WJBscribe|'''WjB''']][[User talk:WJBscribe|scribe]]</font> 02:30, 9 July 2008 (UTC) |
|||
|} |
|||
<small><center>This message delivered by [[User:MediationBot1|MediationBot]], an automated bot account [[Wikipedia:Mediation Committee#MediationBot|operated]] by the [[Wikipedia:Mediation Committee|Mediation Committee]] to perform case management.<br>If you have questions about this bot, please [[Wikipedia talk:Mediation Committee|contact the Mediation Committee directly]].</small></center> |
Revision as of 08:57, 9 July 2008
Redirect to: